Heritage: Questions You're Asking About Cakes, Gays, and Religious Freedom



Cases have been popping up across the country where individuals have declined to bake cakes or take photos for same-sex wedding ceremonies—and government has punished them. This week, Arizona Governor Jan Brewer (R) vetoed a bill that would have put religious liberty protections in place in her state. We sat down with Ryan Anderson, Heritage’s William E. Simon Fellow in Religion and a Free Society, to get some answers about this debate.

The Foundry: How did people’s beliefs about same-sex marriage become an issue for private businesses?

Ryan Anderson: In New Mexico, a photographer declined to use her artistic talents to promote a same-sex ceremony because of her religious beliefs. The couple complained and the New Mexico Human Rights Commission ordered her to pay a fine of nearly $7,000. Christian adoption and foster-care agencies in Massachusetts, Illinois, and Washington, D.C., have been forced to stop providing those services because they believe that the best place for kids is with a married mom and dad. Other cases include a baker, a florist, a bed-and-breakfast, a student counselor, the Salvation Army, and more.

Whose liberty is at stake? Is it just business owners’?

Everyone’s. When the government starts forcing people to do things that violate their deeply held beliefs, we have a problem. Unless the government proves that there is a compelling government interest in doing so (and that there was not another, less restrictive means possible), citizens should be left free. We need legislation protecting religious liberty for all, because in a growing number of cases, government coercion and penalties have violated religious freedom.

Why is this a religious liberty issue?

Many religions teach that marriage is the union of a man and woman, and the religious liberty concern in these recent cases is that people are being coerced into violating that belief. While Americans are legally free to live and love as they choose, no one should demand that government coerce others into participating in activities that violate their sincerely held religious beliefs.

But isn’t government supposed to guarantee equal treatment for all?

These are cases of private individuals offering (or not offering) their services, not government officially recognizing same-sex relationships—which is another case altogether. There is no need for government to try to force every photographer and every florist to service every marriage-related event.

Would laws like these open the door to lots of businesses discriminating against gays and lesbians?

Claims that proposals like Arizona’s encourage refusing service to gays and lesbians are simply nonsensical. Arizona’s proposed legislation never even mentioned same-sex couples or sexuality; it simply clarified and improved existing state protections for religious liberty.

Some people have claimed, for example, that it meant a pharmacy could refuse to serve gays and lesbians. But I know of no sincere religious belief that says you can’t sell penicillin to someone because they are gay or lesbian. Ensuring that all citizens have access to crucial medical care is a compelling government interest. And requiring every pharmacy to sell penicillin might very well be the least restrictive means possible of ensuring access.

What about people whose religions say different things, or Americans who choose not to practice a religion?

These types of freedom protections are important for all Americans. As Cato’s Ilya Shapiro put it, “For that matter, gay photographers and bakers shouldn’t be forced to work religious celebrations…and environmentalists shouldn’t be forced to work job fairs in logging communities.” When it comes to this particular issue, all Americans should remain free to believe and act in the public square based on their beliefs about marriage without fear of government penalty.


Continue Reading


  1. alnga

    February 28, 2014 at 7:21 pm

    off the shelf you must sell it. special presentation of a known sin….no dice.

  2. lraivala

    February 28, 2014 at 11:50 pm

    Like alnga said below, If it is in a can, Yes. Otherwise NO.. But here is a different take on that same question. Would you want someone who hates you or your partner making the cake or whatever it is?
    That question is why I think it is just a liberal LGBT agenda tactic to do nothing more than shut these businesses down.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Politics4 hours ago

Wealthy Dems Sanders, Warren And Moore Hold Townhall On Income Inequality

Senator Bernie Sanders (I-VT), Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-MA), producer Michael Moore and economist Darrick Hamilton just hosted a townhall on...

Politics6 hours ago

Parkland Students Claim NRA Threatened Them Over Advocating Gun Control

Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School high school students David Hogg and Emma González told CBS News that the NRA has...

Donald Trump8 hours ago

Van Jones Says Trump’s Death Penalty for Drug Dealers Is Divisive, Stupid And A Complete Nonstarter

CNN talking head and former Green Jobs Czar Van Jones said that President Trump was unrealistic and not compassionate enough...

Donald Trump1 day ago

Dem Congressman Suggests Using Second Amendment Against Trump

Rep. Tom Suozzi, a Democratic congressman from Long Island, New York, implied that Americans should grab weapons and oppose President...

Hillary Clinton1 day ago

Clinton Sorry Women Misinterpreted Quip About Husbands Forcing Wives To Vote Trump

While in India, Hillary Clinton managed to insult most of America and especially women, by claiming that their husbands, brothers...

culture1 day ago

Jim Carrey Slammed For Mocking, Garish Cartoon Depicting Sarah Sanders

In recent years, actor/comedienne Jim Carrey has taken up painting as an art form. He also does political cartoons. His...

News2 days ago

McCabe Threatened to ‘Take People Down With Him if Fired’

Just days before FBI Deputy Director Andrew McCabe was terminated, he threatened to “take people down with him” if he...

Politics2 days ago

Eric Holder Challenges GOP: “You want to have a knife fight, we’re gonna do it.”

Former Attorney General Eric Holder in Milwaukee begged liberal activists to turn out and fight for a candidate there. He...

Politics2 days ago

David Hogg Anti-Gun Ad: ‘What If Our Politicians Weren’t the B***h of the NRA?’

David Hogg, the Parkland, Florida student behind the anti-gun protests, has made a propagandic gun control PSA that asks, “What...

culture3 days ago

People Pretent Well

I’m sick of you. All of you. Calling me the worst names just because I’m trying to help you out...

Recent Comments

Copyright © 2017 IHaveTheTruth.com